
Benyamin Netanyahu in his official portrait, gaze fixed on the lens. Head of the Israeli government, he is calling for the identification of the witnesses in the documentary ‘NAZA’. Credits: Avi Ohayon / Government Press Office of Israel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.
In a letter made public on October 11, the Israeli prime minister called for the identification of the military personnel interviewed in the documentary NAZA. He is also seeking their prosecution. The film focuses on operations in Gaza. He cites the security of information and Israel’s interests. As the film reaches French theaters, this move directly targets the sources of its filmmakers, whose conclusions are disputed by the army.
Three Officials Urged To Act
Benyamin Netanyahu sent his request to Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara and Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir. Shin Bet chief David Zini is also a recipient. He heads Israel’s internal intelligence service. The letter calls on these officials to identify the people who appear anonymously in the film or took part in its making.
In the excerpts made public, the prime minister calls for a criminal investigation and prosecution for possible violations of information security. He also cites criminal defamation and harm to the country’s diplomatic and security interests. He is notably suspecting the disclosure of classified information, meaning information whose access is restricted for security reasons.
Netanyahu denounces a narrative he considers false and damaging to Israel and its army. His initiative therefore targets the people who supplied information to the filmmakers, beyond the public dispute over the documentary’s content. The offenses he invokes are the grounds for his request, without establishing the witnesses’ criminal liability.
Earlier Military Steps, Still-Unclear Next Moves
The prime minister’s intervention extends steps announced in September. Eyal Zamir had asked the army’s legal officials to examine possible action against the film’s participants. He also ordered checks into possible leaks of classified documents used in its production.
These announcements do not amount to confusing an internal review, a criminal investigation, and prosecutions. The first can help determine which facts warrant investigation. Prosecutions then require a decision targeting specific offenses and specific people.
As of October 13, the formal opening of a criminal proceeding in response to the October 11 letter has not been publicly confirmed. No indictment of the witnesses has been confirmed either. The scope of any possible investigations, their precise legal basis, and the decisions of the recipient institutions remain to be determined.
The request to reveal identities also leaves one question open: by what means would the authorities seek to obtain them? The letter alone does not amount to a court order compelling journalists to hand over their sources. No such mechanism has been established at this stage.
What The Film Says
NAZA is directed by Israeli filmmakers Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, with the Guardian in production. The film draws on anonymous testimony from 24 members of the Israeli military and intelligence services. It examines target selection in Gaza, the use of artificial intelligence systems, and anticipated civilian casualties before strikes.
According to the documentary, the practices described by its witnesses enabled attacks with known deadly consequences for those in charge. Many Palestinian civilians are said to have been hit. These accusations concern the military chain’s rules and choices. They must be distinguished from a criminal finding established by a court.
According to the filmmakers, the title refers to a Hebrew military acronym for collateral damage. In this context, the phrase notably covers expected civilian deaths during an operation. The film asks what soldiers know before a strike and the level of casualties they are willing to accept.
The Israeli army rejects these accusations. In its October 1 response, it says the film distorts its strike-preparation and authorization process. It argues that its rules forbid deliberately targeting civilians and require precautions to limit casualties. It acknowledges using artificial intelligence tools to propose targets, but says final decisions are made by humans.
Anonymity And Verification At The Heart Of The Dispute
The army also disputes the scope of the testimony. It says the speakers mainly describe the early stages of intelligence work, without having a full view of strike authorization. The production rejects that portrayal.
In a response published on October 1, the Guardian says the participants worked at different stages, up to final authorization. The British paper is acting here as the documentary’s producer and responding to criticism of its own reporting.
It says the team interviewed more than 100 sources over three years, including commanders involved in strike authorization. The 24 people on screen therefore represent only part of the people consulted, according to the production.
The Guardian says it cross-checked the testimony against confidential documents and verified specific strikes. It also says it obtained confirmation from sources not shown in the film. This stated method explains the basis for the production’s confidence. It does not make the confidential material available to the public and does not allow each allegation to be treated as independently proven.
The search for identities thus affects one condition of this journalistic investigation: the confidentiality promised to the witnesses. The production believes the government move is meant to deflect attention from the questions the film raises about civilian deaths in Gaza.
Threats Condemned By Press Freedom Advocates
Pressure on the sources comes after pressure on the filmmakers. In September, Netanyahu had announced plans to allow the revocation of citizenship for Israelis accused of defaming the army abroad. He explicitly named the documentary and its creators.
On September 17, the Committee to Protect Journalists condemned that announcement. It called for dropping measures meant to punish journalism in the public interest. The organization said at the time that the announced provisions had not become law.
Reporters Without Borders also voiced support for the filmmakers on September 30. The NGO denounced the intimidation and threats aimed at them. These statements concern the ability to investigate and publish without retaliation. They do not settle the military accusations laid out in the film.
A Battle That Accompanies The French Release
The dispute extends to distribution. Israeli diplomatic missions have promoted a counter-documentary, NAZA: The Real Story. Its creators, Roi Danino, Ariel Averbuch, and Hagay Gutman, say they financed the 49-minute film themselves. They deny any government or military support for its production. Its promotion by Israeli institutions therefore does not prove an official state commission.
NAZA, which won the Special Jury Prize at the Venice Film Festival in September, is continuing its international run. The Guardian says it will screen in more than 50 countries, a scope that does not mean simultaneous showings everywhere.
In France, special screenings are scheduled for October 12 and 13. Pathé lists a release date of October 12 and a runtime of 1 hour 17 minutes.