After October 17 unrest, France’s justice minister urges civic-rights bans, but only judges can impose them

On March 27, 2025, Gérald Darmanin appears in the foreground at a Franco-British meeting on organized crime and irregular immigration. The Minister of Justice is now calling for a tougher criminal response. Credits: Andy Taylor / Home Office, CC BY 2.0.

On March 27, 2025, Gérald Darmanin appears in the foreground of a Franco-British meeting on organized crime and irregular immigration. The Minister of Justice is now calling for a tougher criminal response. Credit: Andy Taylor / Home Office, CC BY 2.0.

On Thursday, October 22, in Fleury-Mérogis, Gérald Darmanin announced a new directive to prosecutors. He is asking them to seek the loss of civic rights against people prosecuted after the violence of October 17 and 18. This penalty can strip a convicted person of the right to vote, but only a judge can impose it, in the cases provided for by law. The minister’s announcement therefore does not, by itself, suspend any voting rights suspension France electoral rights.

A Circular To Guide The Criminal Response

The Minister of Justice is targeting violence against police officers and gendarmes, looting of businesses, and attacks on public buildings. He is asking prosecutors to seek this penalty “in most cases,” according to his statements on October 22. He is also calling for bans on protesting and suspensions of social media accounts. He is asking for appeals against decisions he considers not sufficiently aligned with his criminal policy.

In his interview with LCI, the minister sums up his intention. “You don’t get to vote in the next election when you’ve looted stores or attacked police officers.” However, the full text of the circular could not be consulted. The specific offenses targeted and the recommended durations remain to be confirmed.

The Prosecutor Requests, The Judge Decides

A circular guides prosecutors’ actions, but it does not create a penalty. Article 30 of the Code of Criminal Procedure authorizes the minister to issue general instructions. He can never intervene by instruction in an individual case.

At the hearing, the prosecutor requests a sanction: these are the submissions. The judge then decides on guilt and the sentence, without being bound by that request. They must take into account the facts and each person’s situation. A prison sentence does not therefore automatically result in the loss of the right to vote: the judgment must expressly impose it.

This deprivation is already provided for certain acts of violence, theft, or damage, depending on their criminal classification. It may therefore apply to the incidents mentioned by the minister, provided each defendant’s responsibility is established. Mere presence in a march is not enough.

The loss of civic rights can last up to five years for a misdemeanor and ten years for a felony. These maximums do not prejudge the penalties that will be chosen. The judge also determines which rights are affected. Being barred from running in an election, and thus being ineligible, does not necessarily mean losing the right to vote.

On April 29, 2019, Gérald Darmanin is still Minister of Public Action and Accounts. Seven years later, as Minister of Justice, he puts the deprivation of civil rights at the center of the debate. Credits: Jacques Paquier, CC BY 2.0.
On April 29, 2019, Gérald Darmanin is still Minister of Public Action and Accounts. Seven years later, as Minister of Justice, he puts the deprivation of civil rights at the center of the debate. Credits: Jacques Paquier, CC BY 2.0.

Protesting And Using Social Media: Separate Penalties

The other sanctions requested follow their own rules. A ban on protesting can last up to three years, in places defined by the court, for certain offenses committed during a protest. It is distinct from a prefectural order banning a gathering.

Suspension of social media accounts, for its part, applies only to certain offenses, when those accounts were used to commit the offense. It can last six months, or one year in the event of legal recidivism. Being prosecuted after street violence is therefore not enough to make this penalty applicable.

A Judicial Record Still Incomplete

In Fleury-Mérogis, Gérald Darmanin announced 2,700 people taken into police custody and 217 prison sentences after the weekend’s violence. He does not specify how many people are being held before trial and how many are already serving a sentence. These incarcerations therefore cannot be presented as convictions.

On LCI, the minister also says that many losses of civic rights have already been handed down. Without a detailed count or case reference, this statement does not make it possible to know how many actually concern the right to vote.

The Requested Toughness Draws Criticism

On Friday, October 23, Romain Boulet criticized on France Inter what he sees as pressure being exerted on the courts. The lawyer is co-chair of the Criminal Defense Lawyers Association. He accuses the Minister of Justice of favoring tougher penalties over accurate ones. His criticism concerns the entire criminal response to the violence.

The minister, for his part, cites the seriousness of the attacks against law enforcement and businesses. The electoral consequences of his requests will depend on the judgments and the rights actually barred, not on the number of arrests.

This article was written by Christian Pierre.